What is it like to engage in talks with Russian officials concerning the war in Ukraine?
This inquiry has piqued considerable curiosity following several recent sessions of ceasefire talks, which have so far appeared to produce little progress four years since the full-scale military offensive.
A further round of US-mediated discussions is likely to occur in Geneva in the coming days. Ahead of it, a key member of Ukrainian President Zelensky's delegation, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has been involved in recent military-to-military talks, has shared his perspective.
As stated by Kyslytsya, these dealings are business-like and mostly free of the type of political and rhetorical posturing observed elsewhere by Moscow.
"The military have a better understanding of the realities in the battlefield," he remarked during a meeting earlier this week.
"The question remains if they [the Russians] are capable, or not, of relaying information accurately…without cooking or distorting the facts," he added.
It is far from an easy task to try to end a major conflict. The nature of the battlefield in eastern Ukraine - where thousands of unmanned aerial vehicles patrol and strike over a vast so-called "grey zone" separating the two sides, while two hundred thousand Ukrainian residents still live in the "heavily fortified" cities of the eastern region - makes the technical process of disengagement highly complex.
"It is essential to establish a precise set of rules and procedures," Kyslytsya explained, "along with a method to confirm and monitor."
The Involvement of International Parties
Much of these preparations, he noted, is complete, thanks in part to the close participation of American representatives, including a senior NATO commander and a high-ranking Army official.
It's obviously not in Kyiv's benefit to criticise representatives of the current US government, but when Kyslytsya compliments the American team for its work, he comes across as genuine.
"We have to credit the Americans for their commitment and their patience," he says, "since they attend the sessions continuously. They don't only watch…they ask questions and they listen to our responses."
The negotiator was similarly complimentary about the roles of the former president's adviser, whom he described as "not a novice", and wealthy mediator Steve Witkoff, whom he characterized as "a much wiser individual than the caricature image often presented in the press".
The United States, he asserted, will play a key function in monitoring any potential ceasefire, with capabilities encompassing satellite and other types of advanced surveillance.
"It is necessary to have an entity who will serve as adjudication, because if there is a breach there must be a neutral actor that is reliable [and] respected."
Past and Present Monitoring Challenges
During an eight-year period prior to Russia's major invasion in recent years, this monitoring role was handled by the OSCE - a body whose restricted resources and absence of enforcement mechanisms rendered it largely incapable of averting an escalation.
"That was quite an achievement [for them] just to operate two drones flying above the territory," he said. "It's kind of the Flintstones era in contrast with what we have now."
In comparison, latest analyses suggest that as many as twelve thousand drones are active above the single city of a frontline city at any given moment.
A Personal Account on Facing the Adversary
Inquired about his ability to negotiate directly from emissaries representing a head of state in the Kremlin who has been willing to sacrifice more than a million of his own men to conquer Ukraine, the diplomat, also a former UN ambassador, provided his answer.
He explained that he'd had a long time of experience.
"I saw far more difficult situations. I served a five-year term in New York, a portion before the major war. I regularly had to sit in the room with the enemy on a frequent basis."
A particular night is seared in his memory: 23 February 2022.
During an emergency Security Council meeting, called to discuss the looming threat in Ukraine, the ambassador got word that his homeland was being assaulted.
Simultaneously, far away to the east in Kyiv, the first distant detonations signaled as Russia's total assault on the nation began.
During moments of intense tension, the ambassador tried to persuade Russia's ambassador, the Russian envoy, to contact his boss, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, to obtain assurances that Moscow's forces would not invade.
"I have stated all I know today," Nebenzia responded, according to his Ukrainian colleague. "I'm not going to wake the minister at this hour."
Everyone's lives were transformed at that instant. The diplomat remained at the UN for another three years prior to going back to the Ukrainian capital.
The Road Ahead
Should the delegations meet again in Geneva this week, he will participate, still thrashing out the contours and mechanics of a halt in fighting but waiting all the while for the most important part of the puzzle to fall into place.
"The war might be ended by simply one call of an individual to his military chief of staff," he said.
"However, the Russian president [Vladimir Putin] is not prepared for stopping the conflict at present."